The Lunacy of Online Hype

Guest Correspondence

BY DONAL O'SHEA SRQ DAILY SATURDAY PERSPECTIVES EDITION SATURDAY JUL 9, 2016

What is it about online education that evokes truly idiotic pronouncements from seemingly thoughtful people?

Despite the availability of superb training videos and simulators, no one who would suggest that mastering a sport could be done entirely online. Indeed, the notion that online learning could supplant sports training camps and coaches in, say, football or soccer seems so naive that it is hard to know where to begin to criticize it. You can repeatedly watch a video showing how to throw a football or head a soccer ball, but nearly everyone understands that timing and practice matter. It almost goes without saying that teamwork must be practiced, and that coaching and motivation matter. Competition with other teams and collaboration with teammates elicit better performance.  

So, why do so many seemingly rational individuals opine publicly and unembarrassedly that online education will result in the demise of traditional university campuses? Consider any academic discipline with which you are comfortable—dance, history, philosophy, sociology, mathematics, chemistry, whatever—and imagine trying to master and learn to use that discipline entirely online. Not impossible maybe, but as unlikely as learning to play football well entirely online.    

We humans are intensely social. We learn best from others, and in the presence of others. We get discouraged and need encouragement and coaching. Mastering any substantial concept—natural selection, oxidation-reduction, rate of change—requires practice and testing in different contexts. And we learn best when we are in an environment where others are learning and interested in the same thing. We learn from each other, and from unmediated interaction between student and student, and student and professor.  

All of this is common sense, well known to anyone who has ever taught or who has ever struggled to master something difficult.  

But the past also offers some pretty compelling guidance. Our oldest universities date to well before the printing press, which was invented in 1436. By 1500, printing presses had popped up all over Europe and produced more than 20 million books. Any person of that time could be forgiven for thinking that cheaper, easily available books would have put the fledgling universities out of business.

But they did not. Quite the contrary.

Universities developed libraries, and books became an essential part of the instruction. Just as with books, online education will be an important component in how we teach and how we learn, and will help make it possible to learn more, faster. But as long as we humans continue to enjoy others’ physical presence, high quality residential universities will be the places of choice for achieving high-level disciplinary mastery, and for learning work with and to understand others. Count on it.   

Donal O'Shea is president of New College of Florida.

« View The Saturday Jul 9, 2016 SRQ Daily Edition
« Back To SRQ Daily Archive

Read More

What Will Single Member Districts Really Mean?

Among the litany of issues Sarasota County voters consider this year will be whether to switch to single-member districts when electing county commissioners. It’s fairly easy to see why this inspires sharp partisan divide. Democrats lament no one from the blue team has won a seat on the com

Jacob Ogles | Oct 13, 2018

District 72 Remains Region's Hottest House Race

An unexpected contest and surprising upset this year turned state House District 72 into the center of the political world in February. This November, voters weigh in again, and while the race this time will be one of many in the region, it remains one of the marquis battles in the region.

Jacob Ogles | Sep 22, 2018

Letting Go at Ringling

We have had the great pleasure at Ringling College of Art and Design this past week of welcoming the largest incoming freshman class in the history of our institution. That’s right, over 500 new young people, representing 42 different states and 30 diverse countries, arrived in Sara

Dr. Larry Thompson | Aug 25, 2018

Good and Graham Swinging for Glass Ceiling

As the woman who could become Florida’s first female governor stumped in Sarasota this week, she turned to the region’s biggest Democratic star for a boost. State Rep. Margaret, D-Sarasota, took the stage at the Francis Thursday to throw her personal support behind gubernatorial candi

Jacob Ogles | Jul 28, 2018