The Missing Button Brings Coastal Charm to Burns Court
Business
SRQ DAILY MONDAY BUSINESS EDITION
MONDAY NOV 16, 2026 |
BY MALLORY EVANS
Pictured: Co-founder Kelli Lovejoy-Dailey says a huge sailing mural gives a good foundation of The Missing Button's overall design. Photo courtesy Tim and Kelli Lovejoy-Dailey.
A narrative-driven “new heritage” boutique recently made its way to Sarasota’s Burns Court—and its name pays homage to a unique piece of history.
On September 29, husband-and-wife duo Tim and Kelli Lovejoy-Dailey opened The Missing Button, a 1920s maritime-inspired parlor specializing in women’s and men’s coastal apparel, artisanal provisions, and accessories. After meeting 25 years ago while working at Lands’ End and serving as design executives for several brands for 40 years, the Lovejoy-Daileys mixed their experience with a passion to curate their own store.
“We fell in love with Burns Court, and there’s a degree of authenticity down here with architectural details, cobblestone and a rich history,” Tim says. “We felt like this was the perfect place for us to do this.”
Tim explains that the boutique’s name connects to the Burns Court neighborhood, founded in 1925 by Owen Burns and his wife, Vernona Freeman. A legend reads that while the Burns were sailing back from Havana during a storm, a button flew off of Freeman’s jacket and was lost at sea. When asked if she wanted to replace the button, Freeman said the jacket was “perfect” without it.
“We’re trying to do things that are classic and timeless—that the older they get, the more you’ll love them,” says Tim.
Kelli says guests can expect an immersive experience of organized storytelling—and many easter egg moments. The Missing Button sells woven shirts, dresses and skirts, along with men’s pants, polos and linen shirts. Blue and white color palettes, stripes and intricate collars are staples, and visitors can also browse jewelry, candles, home decor and barware.
“Since the store has opened, we’ve had so many neighbors come in, and they’re just so friendly,” Kelli says.
Curated acoustics, rich architectural textures and signature aromas complement every corner of the shop. The Lovejoy-Daileys display story cards of all of their vendors, and Tim says they try to select brands that have coastal heritage, such as those made in Charleston or Martha’s Vineyard.
“This store really is an extension of us and what we love,” Tim says.
The couple says consumer relationships are their favorite part of the business, and Kelli adds that they hope to become a destination in Burns Court and downtown Sarasota.
606 S Pineapple Ave., Sarasota, 941-221-0261
Pictured: Co-founder Kelli Lovejoy-Dailey says a huge sailing mural gives a good foundation of The Missing Button's overall design. Photo courtesy Tim and Kelli Lovejoy-Dailey.
« View The Monday Nov 16, 2026 SRQ Daily Edition
« Back To SRQ Daily Archive