Who's on Turkey Duty?

Good Bite

Pictured: A Thanksgiving feast at Brine. Photo by Abbi Henigman.

Somebody has to wrestle the bird into the oven on Thanksgiving morning. This year, four local kitchens volunteer, so book a table or carry the feast home.

Libby’s Neighborhood Restaurant, fresh from facelifts at its Southside Village and Lakewood Ranch locations, serves a holiday plate alongside its regular fare. “We’re really focusing on American favorites,” says partner Kristi Sabella. Favorites include oven-roasted turkey breast and sage brioche stuffing soaking up mushroom cream gravy. Mashed sweet potatoes nuzzle hot honey carrots for a sweet, peppery bite.

Sister restaurant 83 Tavern in Palmer Ranch dishes up turkey and fixings paired with, word has it, the coldest martinis in town. “We call it premium casual,” says owner Joe Seidensticker. “You can use it as a nice night out or a casual tavern or just a cozy place.” For the holiday, the chefs draw on “things they remember from childhood,” he says.

Few dining rooms feed a holiday crowd like GROVE in Lakewood Ranch, where the crew has served around 7,000 guests on Thanksgiving. The Grand Buffet includes turkey and prime rib carving stations while home hosts cart away the Family Feast, complete with Boursin-buttered dinner rolls, pumpkin pie and a bottle of Chardonnay.

Brine Seafood & Raw Bar in Gulf Gate once kept its doors closed on Thanksgiving. “We felt like there was a calling for it in the community,” says chef and co-owner Gary Mazan, now cooking Brine’s second holiday service. Beside the full menu, he's offering an encore of prime rib, with a prosciutto and Parmesan-loaded baked potato. “We sold out of that early, so I’m going a bit heavier with that this year,” he says. Traditionalists get a Joyce Farms turkey breast roulade with herb stuffing, plus a confit leg, with green bean almondine. Nueske’s bacon cream corn and cranberry compote fill out the plates. “There’s a lot more people going out to eat in restaurants these days and not wanting to cook at home,” Mazan says. “It’s a lot of work.”

Libby’s Neighborhood Restaurant, 10 am-9 pm, 1917 S. Osprey Ave., Sarasota, 941-236-5826; 8445 Lorraine Rd., Lakewood Ranch, 941-357-1570, eatatlibbys.com; dine in or pre-order for pickup. 83 Tavern, 10 am- 9 pm, 8383 S. Tamiami Trl., Suite 108, Sarasota, 941-203-5312, 83tavern.com; dine in or pre-order for pickup. GROVE, Grand Buffet 10:30 am- 5 pm, 10670 Boardwalk Loop, Lakewood Ranch, 941-893-4321, grovelwr.com/thanksgiving; to-go orders due by 3 p.m. Nov. 25. Brine Seafood & Raw Bar, 11 am-last seating 7:30 pm, 2250 Gulf Gate Dr, Sarasota, 941-952-3039, brinesarasota.com.

Pictured: A Thanksgiving feast at Brine. Photo by Abbi Henigman.

« View The Tuesday Nov 17, 2026 SRQ Daily Edition
« Back To SRQ Daily Archive

Read More

Lefty's Presents Shell and Tell, The Party

Lefty's Presents Shell and Tell, The Party

Nov 10, 2026

A General Store at the Beach

A General Store at the Beach

Sarah Emily Miano | Nov 10, 2026

Gecko's Grill and Pub Hosts Pours & Paws Wine Tasting and Five-Course Wine  Dinner Benefiting Love4Paws

Gecko's Grill and Pub Hosts Pours & Paws Wine Tasting and Five-Course Wine Dinner Benefiting Love4Paws

Nov 3, 2026

Mitchell's Moves In

Mitchell's Moves In

Sarah Emily Miano | Nov 3, 2026