National Pumpkin Cheesecake Day Has Never Been Cuter

Good Bite

Photo courtesy of the restaurant

Though it may feel like an endless summer, it is finally fall in Sarasota. The sun is setting a little earlier. Jack-o-lanterns make appearances on porches and patios. The weather will (hopefully) begin to cool down. And most importantly, pumpkin spice-flavored everything is making its annual comeback. If the autumnal equinox was not enough of a reason to indulge in the fruit of the season, then maybe National Pumpkin Cheesecake Day will persuade you to. 

The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe is an up-and-coming bakery and cafe on Holmes Beach. Owned and operated by Jennifer Geils, the restaurant’s colorful menu is stuffed with sandwiches, flatbreads, overnight oats and cheesecakes–specifically that of the pumpkin variety. With a dedicated cheesecake menu, Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe offers an array of flavors ranging from original to blueberry lemon to Snickers. And now for fall, the bakery (or shall we say cheesecakery) is selling a pumpkin spice flavored Cutie (personal-sized) cheesecake—available individually, by the half dozen or by the dozen. And as if that weren’t enough, Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe also has the Thankful Sailor cheesecake–made with a housemade pumpkin spice seasoning infused into the cheesecake and topped with homemade whipped cream–and a gluten-free version of their pumpkin Cutie. All three fall-inspired desserts are available now through Christmas. 

Celebrate National Pumpkin Cheesecake Day this Thursday, October 21 with Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe. And while you’re there, try any of their other 20+ flavors. Because you can never have too much cheesecake, right? 

The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe, 3324 E. Bay Drive, Holmes Beach, 941-779-2253, cheesecakecutie.com, @cheesecake_cutie

Photo courtesy of the restaurant

« View The Tuesday Oct 19, 2021 SRQ Daily Edition
« Back To SRQ Daily Archive

Read More

Two Years, Zero Shortcuts: Two Chefs' Intentional Return

Two Years, Zero Shortcuts: Two Chefs' Intentional Return

Sarah Emily Miano | Feb 17, 2026

Sizzling Sisig Ends Sarasota's Long Wait

Sizzling Sisig Ends Sarasota's Long Wait

Sarah Emily Miano | Feb 10, 2026

 Petrichor Brings Quality Brew, Functional Beverages and Farm-Fresh Fungi  to Northgate Plaza

Petrichor Brings Quality Brew, Functional Beverages and Farm-Fresh Fungi to Northgate Plaza

Sarah Emily Miano | Feb 3, 2026

Get the Scoop

Scoops and Sprinkles Creamery crafts delicious treats

Kate Wight | Jan 31, 2026