Sarasota County Chose the Law Over the Loudest Room

Guest Correspondence

Provided photo.

On Tuesday, the Sarasota County Commission voted 3-2 to stop fighting the Live Local Act. It was the right decision. It also came seven months and six lawsuits too late.

This was never a close legal call. On April 3, the County Attorney warned commissioners in writing that under the plain text of the 2025 law, the county's rural and estate zoning districts appeared to qualify for Live Local projects, and that defending the opposite position would be an uphill battle. Four days later, the commission voted 5-0 to adopt that position anyway.

The warnings kept coming. Outside counsel hired by the county reached the same conclusion. In September, the Florida Attorney General, at the county's own request, issued an opinion saying the county was wrong. On Nov. 4, Circuit Judge Hunter Carroll ruled against the county in the D.R. Horton case and ordered it to process the application. The Attorney General filed an amicus brief in the separate SITC case making the same point. And on the day of the ruling, County Attorney Joshua Moye told the board, "We all knew it was an uphill battle going against the plain language of the Live Local Act."

Five legal opinions. One answer.

Think of it this way. The speed limit on your street is 35. You think it should be 70, so instead of asking to have it changed, you just drive 70. You get a ticket. The prosecutor tells you the limit is 35. The judge finds you guilty. Do you appeal because you still think it should be 70? Of course not. You never challenged the law. You simply broke it.

That is what the county did, and it is not cheap. The Live Local Act requires the county to pay the winning side's attorney fees, up to $250,000 per case. There are six pending cases. That is as much as $1.5 million before counting the county's own legal bills, and some plaintiffs are arguing for more.

The bigger risk sits in Tallahassee. As of this month, counties must report their Live Local litigation to the state, and that information goes to the Governor, the Senate President and the House Speaker before the next state budget is written. Manatee County learned what happens when a local government defies state law: it lost its state infrastructure money. With Amendment 3 squeezing the county budget, Sarasota cannot afford to put millions in state funding at risk to make a point.

Money aside, the core issue is simple. Every commissioner swore an oath to uphold the law, including the laws they dislike. That oath exists so decisions rest on the rule of law, not the size of the crowd. Governing by the crowd is mob rule.

On Tuesday, about 60 people asked the commission to keep breaking the law. Two commissioners said yes. Three weighed five consistent legal opinions and said no.

If residents want the Live Local Act changed, the place to make that case is Tallahassee. Until then, the law is the law. Three commissioners remembered that, and they deserve our thanks.

Christine Robinson is the Chief Executive Officer of The Argus Foundation.


Provided photo.

« View The Saturday Nov 21, 2026 SRQ Daily Edition
« Back To SRQ Daily Archive

Read More

Before the First Day of Kindergarten

Before the First Day of Kindergarten

Tommy Gregory | Nov 21, 2026

 10 Bold Visions. 8 Transformational Grants. One  Extraordinary Community.

10 Bold Visions. 8 Transformational Grants. One Extraordinary Community.

Pam Kandziora and Sara Winer | Nov 21, 2026

What We’re Watching This Tourism Season

What We’re Watching This Tourism Season

Erin Duggan | Nov 21, 2026

 Belonging Is Built Together

Belonging Is Built Together

Phillip Lanham | Nov 21, 2026